As I started researching whether ABA therapy would be right for my child, I found that there were strong opinions on both sides. I would read one story about how ABA helped a child communicate or become more independent. But then I'd scroll to another from an autistic adult describing a very different experience.
It was difficult to sort through. I wasn't looking for someone to tell me ABA was simply “good” or “bad.” I really wanted to understand the benefits, the concerns, and how this could help my child.
If you're in that same place, this article is meant to help. ABA has research supporting its use, but it also has a complicated history. How therapy is practiced and whether your child’s needs and boundaries are respected matters.
Understanding the pros and cons of ABA therapy can help you ask better questions and decide what feels right for your child and family.
Key Takeaways
- ABA therapy can help some autistic children build communication, daily living, social, and other meaningful skills.
- ABA has also been criticized by autistic adults, particularly when therapy focuses on compliance, suppressing autistic traits, or making a child appear less autistic.
- Good ABA should be individualized, respect a child's communication and boundaries, and focus on skills that improve their quality of life.
- ABA isn't the only option. Speech therapy, occupational therapy, and other supports may be used alongside or instead of ABA depending on your child's needs. If you want help with the next step, you can get started with Alpaca Health.
What ABA Therapy Is and What It Sets Out to Do
Applied Behavior Analysis (ABA) uses principles of learning and behavior to understand why behaviors happen and help people build skills.
An ABA treatment plan for an autistic child can address areas such as communication, daily routines, safety, independence, play, or coping with transitions. The specific goals should depend on the individual child rather than a standard list of behaviors associated with autism.
ABA shouldn't ever aim to cure autism or make a child appear non-autistic. Instead, therapy should focus on skills that are useful and meaningful to the child while respecting who they are.
You don't have to figure this out alone.
Alpaca Health matches your family with a vetted, in-network BCBA, often within days and with no waitlist. We handle the insurance paperwork so you can focus on your child.
Get matched with a BCBA →
The Case for ABA Therapy
Parenting an autistic child comes with its challenges. Families often turn to ABA therapy because they want practical support with skills that affect their child's everyday life. That could mean learning to ask for help, communicating the need for a break, getting dressed more independently, or even safely navigating the community.
What the research supports
ABA therapy has been studied for years, particularly for autistic children. Research suggests behavioral interventions can improve some developmental outcomes, but results vary considerably between children and studies.
This distinction matters. Finding evidence that an intervention can improve certain skills doesn't mean ABA produces the same results for every autistic child. It also doesn't mean that every ABA program is equally effective.
When meeting with an ABA provider, look for specifics. Think about what skill they're expected to improve, how progress will be measured, and whether that will actually be meaningful for your child.
The skills families most often see change
The benefits of ABA will likely look different depending on your child's starting point and treatment goals. You may notice progress in areas such as:
- Functional communication
- Daily living and self-care
- Safety
- Transitions and routines
- Play and participation
- Independence
Your child's progress doesn't always mean they can perform an activity without support. A child who learns to use AAC to ask for a break, for example, has gained a meaningful communication skill even though they're using a support to do it.
Practical Drawbacks Families Should Consider
ABA may come with practical challenges. Your child's treatment plan may require a significant time commitment for both you and your family. Cost may also be a concern. This is especially true when insurance doesn't cover all recommended services.
Another question to ask is whether skills learned during therapy carry over into everyday life. Your child may demonstrate a skill with her therapist but needs additional support to use it at home, school, or in the community.
The Criticism of ABA Therapy
Even though ABA therapy has changed over time, its history still matters. Some autistic adults who received ABA as children described experiences they found distressing or harmful. Their concerns deserve to be a part of the conversation when you're deciding what's right for your child.
The criticisms often center on what behaviors therapy targets. It also matters how much control a child has during therapy and whether the goal is building meaningful skills or simply making an autistic child behave more like their non-autistic peers. The concerns have also prompted discussion within the ABA field about how therapy can better respect autonomy and neurodiversity.
What autistic adults say about their experience
There isn't a single universal autistic perspective on ABA therapy. However, some autistic adults report negative experiences with behavioral interventions, including feeling pressured to comply, having their distress ignored, or being taught to suppress behaviors that help them regulate.
These experiences matter because a treatment can look successful on paper while feeling very different to the person receiving it.
Today, the research and discussion within the field increasingly recognize the importance of including autistic voices when deciding which treatment goals are actually meaningful.
Concerns about compliance and masking
The biggest concern about ABA therapy is whether it prioritizes compliance over communication and autonomy.
Let's take a look at some examples. Teaching a child to make eye contact or keep quiet hands may make them appear more typical without providing a meaningful benefit. ABA therapy should never try to stop harmless stimming simply because the behavior looks different.
Parents have similar concerns about masking, sometimes called camouflaging. Masking happens when autistic people hide or suppress autistic traits to fit social expectations. Research involving autistic adults has linked extensive masking experiences with exhaustion, isolation, poor well-being, and loss of identity.
Keep in mind that teaching autistic children a new skill isn't masking. We make the distinction by asking the important question of why the skill is being taught. Learning to ask for help or safely cross the street serves a child; however, teaching a child to appear less autistic for the comfort of others is different.
How older ABA differs from current practice
Early forms of ABA included approaches that many families and clinicians today would likely find unacceptable. Historically, behavioral programs could emphasize normalization, strict compliance, and the use of aversive consequences.
ABA has evolved considerably since those early programs, with many current practitioners emphasizing positive reinforcement, individualized goals, communication, assent, and quality of life. Researchers have also called for the field to take autistic criticism seriously and incorporate more neurodiversity-affirming practices.
A provider using the term “modern ABA” isn’t a guarantee of good ABA. Practice can still differ from one provider or therapist to another. That's why parents should look closely at how a provider actually treats their child instead of relying on the label alone.
What Changed in Modern ABA
Modern ABA increasingly focuses on helping children build skills that make everyday life easier instead of simply eliminating behaviors that look autistic. Some modern ABA approaches are also more naturalistic or play-based, allowing children to practice skills within activities and situations that resemble everyday life.
Taking a neurodiversity-affirming approach helps prioritize functional communication, independence, safety, self-advocacy, and regulation while respecting harmless autistic behaviors. It also pays closer attention to a child's assent or the way they communicate whether they're comfortable participating.
That means it's reasonable for parents to ask what the goal is and who benefits from it.
For example, your child may rock back and forth while listening to a story. Stopping the rocking shouldn't automatically be considered progress. However, if they run repeatedly into a busy parking lot, building communication and safety skills has a clear benefit.
The difference is whether therapy is helping your child navigate the world more safely and independently or simply teaching them to look less autistic.
If you're looking for an individualized approach that includes your family's priorities, get started with Alpaca Health to learn more about ABA support for your child.
How to Tell Whether a Provider Practices ABA Well
The quality of an ABA provider can vary. A good therapist should be able to explain why each goal matters, how it benefits your child, and how your child's preferences and communications are considered.
Pay attention to how the team reacts when your child says no, pulls away, or shows they don't want to participate. Current discussions around neurodiversity-affirming ABA emphasize choice, self-determination, and goals that improve an autistic person's quality of life.
Questions to ask in a consultation
You don't need to know everything about ABA to ask good questions. Try asking:
- How do you decide which goals to work on?
- How do you involve parents and my child in choosing goals?
- How do you respond if my child doesn't want to participate?
- Do you target stimming, eye contact, or other autistic traits?
- How will I know whether therapy is helping my child?
- What happens if I disagree with a goal or strategy?
A provider should be willing to answer these questions clearly without making you feel pressured to enroll.
Warning signs in a treatment plan
Review your child's goals and be aware of ones that rely heavily on compliance, eye contact, stopping harmless stimming, or making your child more like their peers. If you do have questions, it's acceptable to ask your therapist how these goals benefit your child.
Some other warning signs to look for include ignoring your child's attempts to communicate no or using the same goals for every autistic child. Another warning sign is a provider who discourages you from questioning treatment recommendations. Neurodiversity-affirming approaches increasingly emphasize meaningful goals, self-advocacy, choice, and responsiveness to assent or withdrawal of assent.
Wondering how you'll pay for ABA?
Alpaca Health is in-network with 100+ plans, including Medicaid in the states we serve, and we verify your coverage for free before anything starts.
Check your coverage →
What ABA Therapy Cannot Do
ABA therapy is not a cure for your child's autism. That means it also can't address every need an autistic child may have. ABA can help build specific skills, but your child may still benefit from other professionals for speech and language, sensory or motor needs, mental health, medical concerns, or learning differences.
More than anything, ABA can't tell you who your child should become. Therapy can always teach skills and provide support, but being autistic isn't something your child needs to learn how to hide.
Therapies Families Use Alongside or Instead of ABA
ABA therapy isn't the only therapy that helps autistic children. Depending on your child's needs, some other options may include:
- Speech therapy for communication and language
- Occupational therapy for daily living, motor, or sensory needs
- Physical therapy for movement, balance, and coordination
- Mental health support for concerns such as anxiety or emotional well-being
These therapies may be used alongside or instead of ABA, depending on your child's individual needs.
How to Decide Whether ABA Is Right For Your Child
ABA may not be a good fit for every autistic child.
Before starting ABA therapy, think about what you hope your child will gain from therapy. Then look at the actual goals being proposed and whether they support your child's communication, safety, independence, or quality of life.
How your child responds to ABA therapy matters too; pay attention to whether they feel safe with the therapy team. You also want to see how the provider responds to distress or refusal and whether you're comfortable with the approach.
What to Do if ABA Is Not Working for Your Child
If you have concerns about your child's therapy or progress, talk with their BCBA. Be specific about what you're noticing and ask why a particular goal or strategy is being used.
You can then ask about changes to the treatment plan or discuss whether another approach might be better for your child's needs. Changing providers or stopping ABA doesn't mean you're giving up on support. It may simply mean your child needs something different.
How Alpaca Health Helps Families Weigh ABA Therapy
Choosing ABA therapy involves more than simply being told your child needs it. Families should understand the goals, how progress is going to be measured, and what therapy will look like for their child.
Alpaca Health works with families to develop individualized ABA plans based on each child's needs and priorities.
Choosing What Works for Your Child
The pros and cons of ABA therapy aren't going to be the same for every child. What matters most is whether the therapy your child receives is respectful, individualized, and helping them build meaningful skills.
You should feel comfortable in a setting where you can ask questions, disagree with the goal, or reconsider therapy when something doesn't feel right.
If you're considering ABA and want to explore an individualized approach, get started with Alpaca Health.
You don't have to figure this out alone.
Alpaca Health matches your family with a vetted, in-network BCBA, often within days and with no waitlist. We handle the insurance paperwork so you can focus on your child.
Get matched with a BCBA →Frequently Asked Questions About ABA Therapy Pros and Cons
What are the disadvantages of ABA therapy?
One disadvantage of ABA therapy is the significant time commitment. The quality of therapy also varies between providers. Other concerns may include approaches that prioritize compliance, suppress harmless autistic traits, or don't adequately respect a child's autonomy.
Why do some autistic adults oppose ABA therapy?
Some autistic adults describe negative experiences with ABA. Some describe feeling pressured to comply, suppress stimming, or appear less autistic. Their experiences are one reason it's important to ask how the provider handles assent, autonomy, and treatment goals.
Is ABA therapy still recommended?
Your child's clinician may recommend ABA therapy for your child. However, whether ABA is appropriate depends on the individual child, their needs, and how therapy is practiced. Families should always discuss treatment options with their child's healthcare and therapy professionals.
What can I try instead of ABA therapy?
Other options may include speech therapy, occupational therapy, physical therapy, mental health support, or other services based on your child's needs. Some children receive these alongside ABA, while others may use different supports instead.
If you're comparing your options, get started with Alpaca Health to learn more about individualized ABA support.
RELATED ARTICLES
